Discussing the Lit Blitz: Lee Ann Setzer's "Night Without Darkness"
Discussing the Lit Blitz, previous finalist Annaliese Lemmon talks with the finalists from our most recent contest about their work.
This interview has been edited for clarity.
Annaliese Lemmon: Welcome, everyone, to the Mormon Lit Lab podcast. I'm Annaliese Lemmon, your host for this series where we discuss the 15th annual Mormon Lit Blitz. Today, I'm joined by Lee Ann Setzer, author of “Night Without Darkness.” Welcome, Lee Ann.
Lee Ann Setzer: Hello! Thanks.
Annaliese Lemmon: And you were on the podcast last year, but for those who may not have listened to that, could you introduce yourself and explain what your experience is with the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints?
Lee Ann Setzer: Yeah, my name is Lee Ann Setzer. I joined the LDS Church in Southern California as a teenager, and now I'm not a teenager, so I've pretty much been there for, boy, for a long history with the LDS Church. I've worked at BYU a couple times. I'm a speech-language pathologist, and right now I'm working as the project director for an early literacy project in the McKay School of Education. And my husband and I have the calling as coordinators for a residential center for adults with disabilities. So, right now I'm in the position that my sacrament meetings have never been more interesting or lovelier than they are right now
Annaliese Lemmon: Hmm. Nice. And once again, you've given us a rich story that delves into some hypothesized cultural practices of the Book of Mormon peoples. And I love that not only do you describe this holiday celebrating the Night Without Darkness, but also how the robbers twisted it in psychological warfare. So what was the process of creating that? Which idea came first?
Lee Ann Setzer: Well, it's just now occurring to me that, it's not just the Night Without Darkness, it's also Christmas itself that probably had an evolutionary proc- Well, okay, we know it did, and there've been a lot of different Christmases. But, when I sit down to write a short story, it very often, if I just say, "I'm gonna write a short story," next thing I know, I'm either writing a Book of Mormon historical fiction or I'm writing an oddball Christmas story. So, a Book of Mormon historical fiction about Christmas in the Book of Mormon was probably inevitable given that.
When I was writing the story, the holiday definitely came first. The story idea, complete with a teenager born on the night of the sign, kicked around in my brain for quite a while, but it only came into focus when I thought about another young person who maybe in a different situation or different setting would've been the love interest on the other side of the conflict, and trying to draw this thin tenuous thread between these two people with such a divide between them.
We sing songs, we share art, and we ponder the night the sign was given as Christmas in Zarahemla. But after that first Christmas, they marked that date every year. So it was fun creating a festival of light all night and then breaking it. When they're under siege, they don't know how long they're gonna be under siege. They have to ration and economize. No one feels much like an all-night party anyway. And the robbers, they came from the same tradition, so they know that. And like you say, that would be a very effective form of psychological warfare.
Annaliese Lemmon: Mm-hmm And I loved hearing about some of the research you used in your last story. And I know I've heard about, I think mining companies would send children in these tunnels that only they could fit through. So I was wondering what research that you did to create these spy tunnels or anything else with this story?
Lee Ann Setzer: Yeah, on the tunnels I can feel the curtain fluttering. [laughs] Do not pay any attention to the person behind the curtain. The research is a little thin, especially about siege warfare in Middle America. But, tunneling and counter-tunneling have been used in siege warfare, more for offense than defense, like tunneling under the city walls.
But, it seemed to me like espionage would be a logical extension of that. And then I think I have the same background knowledge as you do about sending small people into small tunnels, and again, it just made sense to me to expand that into military tunneling.
Annaliese Lemmon: Mm-hmm.
Lee Ann Setzer: And then if you're sheltering an entire population under a siege, you know, they're eating your food, and you probably want to put all of them to work. There are other points in the Book of Mormon when people get really desperate, when the generals say, "We are gonna arm the women and children."
Annaliese Lemmon: Mm-hmm.
Lee Ann Setzer: So, even though it's not documented here at this point, it seemed to me to make sense as a spot where you would put every person who was eating your food to work for you that you possibly could.
Annaliese Lemmon: Absolutely.
Lee Ann Setzer: So those are my thoughts research-wise. Story-wise, I wanted to draw that thread between the defenders and attackers, and there needed to be some way to connect them. And so that's why the tunnels were born.
The research that I was most intrigued with for this, I was kind of positing South American Nephites and Lamanites, and of course, people argue all day where the Book of Mormon takes place.
Annaliese Lemmon: Mm-hmm.
Lee Ann Setzer: But I looked at the information about the Mayan calendar, and they were super excited about birthdays, and birthdays are super important. So in a story where her birthday and the Savior's birthday are both really important, it was fun to have read about that background.
Annaliese Lemmon: Yeah, and that really brought up some interesting character points with her, where she's like, "Well, I'm the same age as the savior is now, but when is he going to die?" And I found that a really intriguing part of your story.
Lee Ann Setzer: Yeah, I kinda hadn't thought about it until I got into it, and Samuel the Lamanite never told them when He was gonna die. He just told them when He was gonna be born, and they're like, "How much longer can we put up with this?" They're in the middle of it. They don't know what’s gonna happen next or how bad it's gonna get.
So, yeah, it was interesting to put myself in the head of an 18-year-old thinking about issues like that.
Annaliese Lemmon: Mm-hmm. So both of these stories dwell on some of the darker stories in the Book of Mormon. So what draws you to these stories particularly? Do you see yourself continuing in this vein, or are you interested in branching out to other stories in the Book of Mormon?
Lee Ann Setzer: You know, it's kind of funny in the Book of Mormon, I was thinking about this morning. I think Mormon, I don't know if he was “drawn” to the darker stories, but you get to 4th Nephi and it's a chapter long. It's 200 years where everybody gets along great and everything is going really well because people are so righteous and so charitable, and he spends a couple pages on it. And I think, you know, as a person writing the Book of Mormon to our future day, he dwelt on the dark stuff because dark stuff is the stuff where there's more for us to learn by seeing the conflict. And as an author, it's the same kind of thing. You want the conflict. You want the stress. You want to see where the system is breaking because the system's not working and ask why.
So, yeah, I don't think I'm drawn toward darkness, but as an author, you gotta be drawn to the conflict.
Annaliese Lemmon: Mm-hmm
Lee Ann Setzer: In general, the reason I keep coming back to the Book of Mormon stories is I'm so drawn to the bit characters, and background characters, people in the crowd scenes, and what would one ordinary person have been thinking? And unfortunately for those guys, they're often suffering for the choices of their corrupt leaders or for the society they're born in, and that's especially the children. They didn't ask to be here. They just got born into the middle of it. And of course, there's so much overlap between whatever the sides are in the particular Book of Mormon story.
You've got your Nephites and Lamanites, and even those lines kind of blur at different places in the Book of Mormon. People call themselves Lamanites or people call themselves Nephites even though that's not what they were born. But you've also got your kingmen, your freemen, and your robbers, and your not robbers in this story.
You've got people in the Church of God, and detractors, and people who are in the Church of God but aren't really Church of God, and always the wicked and the righteous. But, you know, all those categories have some overlap, and I think that really reflects each one of us. We've all got that overlap, too.
Annaliese Lemmon: Yeah.
Lee Ann Setzer: And then also when it's going so fast, when the Pride cycle is going so fast, you know, you would have had neighbors that had lined up to kill you and your family on the night the sign came. And after the sign, everybody fell to their knees. And did you embrace the neighbors that had been lined up the day before to kill you? And did they really trust you after that? And, you know, at the end of this story with the siege, some robbers who were left put down their weapons, and they repented, and they came back. And how do you feel about that if your neighbor's been a robber and now they live next door again?
It's just, really interesting to me.
Annaliese Lemmon: Yeah, I love getting into those little details that you don't always think about when you're reading the scriptures, which is at the high level of detail. And yeah, going back to the conflict, yeah, I think a common writing advice is you chase your characters up a tree and then you set it on fire.
Just because if there wasn't conflict, it would be boring, and that's how life goes. If we have a goal, things get in our way. So we like to read about people that also struggle, I think.
Lee Ann Setzer: I think that's what Mormon thought. And it's kind of funny at the end of 3 Nephi 4 and the beginning of chapter 5, usually Mormon is just telling it straight, you know? He's saying, "Now they were righteous, and now they were unrighteous, and here's what they did, and here's what they didn't do." But kind of at the end of that siege story, you can kind of catch him rolling his eyes. He says, "Their hearts were swollen with joy unto the gushing out of many tears, and there was not a living soul who did doubt in the least the words of all the holy prophets." And you almost hear him at that point saying, "Yeah, right guys." What happens next? [laughs]
Annaliese Lemmon: Mm-hmm. So a question I like to ask everybody is, what is a piece of media, any format, any genre, that you recommend for our audience?
Lee Ann Setzer: You know, this question usually stumps me, but I am right in the middle of Connie Willis' book, To Say Nothing of the Dog: or, How We Found the Bishop's Bird Stump. And it is impossible to describe how hilarious and ridiculous this book is. It's a time travel, romance, mystery, comedy with a cat that's been misplaced in the space time continuum, and that's just where the ridiculousness starts. It is so madcap and nuts. And then I've read it before. It comes out with this perfectly, beautifully executed mystery and a beautifully executed time travel twist, which is just absolutely amazing.
She's got this whole series of... Well, it's not really a series, but it's a bunch of books that all take place in Oxford in the future, and they've created this time travel machine, and that gives her opportunities to go back to, like, the Bubonic plague, and it's just World War II. There's this huge World War II set of books.
And they're all astounding, and they're mostly with darker themes, and you just crawl out the other side exhausted, but also uplifted, and also with a lot to think about. So she's just one of my favorite authors in general, Connie Willis. And she also writes some oddball Christmas stories, so that's either a point where we intersect or maybe a point where she inspired me.
But yeah, anything you can get your hands on by Connie Willis, I just really, really recommend.
Annaliese Lemmon: Okay. Thank you. That does sound quite fun. And do you have any other projects or places to find you online that you'd like to tell us about?
Lee Ann Setzer: Well, I'm, it's a mess right now. I've got this superhero story, and it's just, I thought it was gonna be easy, and it's just eating my lunch. And so I'm kind of at the stage where I'm kind of stalking around it and poking it with a sharp stick and trying to figure out if it's alive.
And the other thing that's come up recently is kind of a tangent, but if you're at the Salt Lake City Library in December, they just accepted a dollhouse that I made. It's a reproduction of Casita from the movie Encanto. so yeah, my upcoming projects are superhero origin stories and teeny tiny landscaping.
Annaliese Lemmon: How fun. Well, thank you so much for joining us. We had a great discussion. Is there anything you'd like to add?
Lee Ann Setzer: No. I think I'm good. Thanks.
Annaliese Lemmon: All right. So thanks again for joining us, and look forward to seeing more of your work.
Lee Ann Setzer: All right. Thank you so much for having me.
To receive updates on the Mormon Lit Blitz and other contests, please subscribe to our newsletter. If you would like to support the Mormon Lit Lab, you can do so on Patreon.




Comments